Word Count: 31,335
Disclaimers: Don't own, don't make money from, just have a helluva lot of fun with.
Warnings: sibling incest, minor character deaths
Summary: What if John Winchester managed to kill Azazel in Season 1? Sam and Dean are just regular run-of-the-mill monster-hunting brothers, until the day they investigate an old abandoned schoolhouse where something supernatural is happening. When Sam switches places with an alternate Sam from a more canon universe, Dean realizes how very lucky he is, and Sam remembers how to trust his brother. This an AU with spoilers up through Season 9.
A/N: The latest in my attempt to import my stories from AO3.
CHAPTER ONE - CHAPTER TWO - CHAPTER THREE - CHAPTER FOUR - CHAPTER FIVE - CHAPTER SIX - CHAPTER SEVEN - CHAPTER EIGHT - CHAPTER NINE
READ IT ON AO3