Other Pairing(if applicable): Oberon/Dean (in the past and not explicit)
Word Count: 22,750
Warnings/Spoilers: some magically-induced non-con elements and implied rape (in the past & off-screen — not between Sam & Dean), bottom!Sam (eventually), “Clap Your Hands If You Believe” follow-up casefic, first time, Season 13 canon-divergent (no Lucifer, Mary, or Jack)
Summary: When people start disappearing in Elmwood, Indiana, Sam and Dean return to the town where they faced one of their strangest cases seven years ago. Revisiting the past dredges up all kinds of long-repressed feelings, and when Dean gets sucked into Faerie again, Sam finds himself facing a foe far more dangerous than the king of the fairies. Rescuing Dean is only the beginning of a journey through the labyrinth of the Winchesters’ complicated love for each other, with no guarantee they’ll make it out alive.
Story: Part One | Part Two | Part Three | Ao3
Art Prompt: The Painting
Author Notes: This story is set in a canon-divergent Season 13, just after 13.19 “Funeralia.” There is no Jack, no Lucifer, no Mary, no other alternate universes except the one here. Crowley is probably still alive and King of Hell, but he doesn’t get mentioned. Created for the 2018 wincest_reverse with thanks to the mods!